• I think it's a great way for Google to gather feedback from its users. Until now, they've done a pretty good job of guessing what people think will be relevant, but this search feedback will provide an additional data point that they're on the right track.
  • Meny Hoffman
    I think it's not a good idea, till now we have trusted Google to do their job by indexing the sites and returning results and not base it by the people rating the sites.

    Meny Hoffman
  • i like so much GOOGLE
  • djbbiz - I think you're right. The votes only change your own results, but I'm just guessing as to what Google might do next with this data. Seems pretty powerful to me. If the people at Google wanted to, they could use this data to affect results for everyone. There are potential problems with people gaming the system (as have been mentioned above), but if they can figure out a way to keep that under control, things could get pretty interesting.
  • djbbiz
    The way I read this, your up or down vote will only affect the way search results will be presented to you in the future. I don't believe at this point the up or down vote will change the order of the results to the general searching population. I see it as more of a customization for yourself unlike social search which affects everyone's experience.
  • salut.
    je vois plus hoos poure une autre avenure de sociale hummen
    mes est se que ya quel qu un qui me ecoute
    est tout le mande connais que la sience na pas de franteire.
    je suis marocaine je ne trouve pas aucain moiyane dans mon peiyé
    ma chanche tombe moi entre les main des vouleure mes je suis intelegon qe luis matnent je demande a le mande libre de sovés cette aidé qui ne revieain pas sur sa plase
    merci poure tout le mande libre
  • For the most part, I'm mixed on the issue. As much as I would love to collect feedback from the crowd, I don't trust it. There are way too many users who wouldn't know a good, useful Web site even if it smacked them in the forehead; to potentially get penalized based on individual surfer ratings is capricious at best for providing qualitative results.

    If I recall, doesn't Google already collect this data by means of click-tracking and JavaScript to already harvest how "useful" a site is? Google already knows which sites have the highest bounce rates to remove them from results pages.

    What I would like to see is AdWords feedback. That is very valuable to get. In a way, like what Facebook has for their ads (thumb up/down). If an advertiser gets low ratings, then it gets reviewed by Google staff.

    I agree with you Justin it would be easy to game (now), but it could be good data to start collecting to see what it means later.

    Just one of my many two cents.
    ~Joe
  • I noticed those little buttons about a week ago in my search, however, I think it is more likely profiling users interests and cleaning up search engine spam.

    That means, tuning AdWords campaigns based on link feedback. Maybe in the future it will influence ranking, but right now that would be too easy to game.

    Best,

    Justin
blog comments powered by Disqus

Search

Subscribe



Facebook Fans

 
.infusionsoft.com