3 Common Email Marketing Mistakes That Will Cost You

April 22, 2010 | by Joseph Manna

3 Common Email Marketing Mistakes That Will Cost YouEmail deliverability is a top concern among small businesses. Quite simply, they want to send messages and know they are received by their prospects and customers. In light of this simple task, there are a few gaffes that can cost you when you send your next email marketing message. I’ll share a few real examples and how to prevent it next time.

A while back, our VP of Technology, Marc Chesley shared the three pillars of email deliverability. This is very important to understand because you will know who’s responsible for making sure your email messages are delivered. (Spoiler alert: email senders burden 33% of the responsibility in email delivery.)

To that end, email deliverability is important to us and we’ve worked hard to implement the best possible infrastructure and forge fruitful relationships with ISPs so our email messages are trusted. We’ve encountered a few more users than normal who have fallen outside of our guidelines and we’ve had to let them go. We hate doing that and we want to share a few key examples all users must consider when they launch their next email marketing campaign.

There are three common mistakes small business owners make when they engage in email marketing.

1. Sending to an Old List.

We know it’s tough to let go of people that you’ve previously emailed before. The consequence of sending to a group of people who haven’t heard from you in over six months is quite severe. If you sent an email to just 1000 people, if two people hit the “Report Spam” in their email software, you risk the odds of all users getting their emails properly delivered. Yes, it’s that serious! The 0.1% industry guideline is mandated from ISPs and burdened by email service providers.

To overcome this – do not email people you have not had recent contact with—we’re talking longer than six months. Email permission typically expires after about nine months and spam complaints go up exponentially after six months. Alternatively, you can use a reconnect campaign via  direct mail like a postcard or letter to help “ignite” their permission again. Permission is key.

2. Sending the Wrong Message at the Wrong Time.

Over the years, small business users grow comfortable sending to their entire list. This can irritate recipients who don’t want every single announcement from your business. What do these people do when they receive a poorly-targeted/timed message? They unsubscribe and report spam. Tough love, eh? This isn’t the time for list scrubbing – it’s the time for targeted, segmented and truly relevant messages to be delivered to your recipients.

The solution is to narrow your broadcasts to smaller groups in your database. With Infusionsoft, you have the technology to segment the interest, needs and previous activity of your subscribers so you only send to the ones who expect your email and are interested in getting specific and targeted information from you.

3. Infrequent, Inconsistent Contact.

Similar to above, sending infrequent, unexpected emails to your subscribers can be just as damaging as sending too often. Email recipients often expect to be notified on a monthly basis, maybe more or less frequent depending on your expectations when they opted-in. You don’t have to write novels when emailing them. It’s important, outright required to exercise discipline when maintaining a quality email relationship with your subscribers.

To address this, a good tactic to employ is to have one message and one call to action for subscribers and spread it out over a period of time. If you plan on changing your email delivery schedule, let them know. One of Infusionsoft’s respected marketers, Perry Marshall, was able to have his list self-segment a “Daily,” “Weekly” and “Monthly” email sequence. He receives nearly zero spam complaints as a result and his recipients receive his messages when they want them. (Not when Perry does.)

I mentioned “cost” in the title, but I haven’t explained it yet. Cost will vary by the type of business you have and how you generate revenue from your contacts. Most universally, making these mistakes will often cost you valuable email relationships as people unsubscribe. The cost could also be that if you don’t heed the best practices in email marketing, your email service provider could drop you for spam. Later, we’ll talk about email marketing ROI.

There is a laundry list of to-dos and don’t-dos out there. I won’t get into those only because it comes down to one thing: respect. Respect your subscribers’ needs and interests and they will reciprocate. These top three mistakes small business email marketers do are often overlooked until after they’ve shot themselves in the foot. Consider this advice before you send your next email marketing broadcast.

[Image credit: kylemay]

 
  • mitchtarr

    I would add to this that there is a good reason to remove people from your list if they have taken NO action in a 12 month period. If someone has not opened anything you've sent them how much of a follower are they really?

    • http://www.joemanna.com/blog/ Joseph Manna

      I would totally agree – no activity is not worth marketing to. People who are on a list over 9 months with no action are a huge risk for email marketers. Thank you for taking the time to share your comments. I look forward to more from you. :)

      ~joseph

  • http://twitter.com/jaredkimball 个Jared Kimball

    I totally agree. The three things that are addressed in this post only touch the very small tip of the iceberg. Which is why I created an entire site dedicated to helping email marketers learn best practices while avoiding spam complaints. Let's face it no one likes to hear the truth when you're the one in the wrong but the truth is still the truth. I offer some useful ideas on how to reconnect with an old list plus many more ideas. Take 3 minutes and learn something new. Follow me on twitter and visit the site.

  • Matthew

    Yes, agree with your comments – but not from a Spam point of view. I'm not totally versed up on American Anti-spam laws, but it seems that most of what I hear coming from email service providers is not to comply with Spam Laws, but rather to keep their own servers whitelisted more 'Easily' with the ISP's.
    I know this post will create some backlash, but does it say anywhere in the American Anti-Spam laws that once a person has double-opted that if they aren't emailed for 6 months that they are no longer double opted-in..? If so, why dont email providers automatically downgrade contacts from double to single opt-in or even stop these emails from being sent?
    Now, while I have said this – I do myself have a policy of keeping regular contact with my clients and I actually actually have a spam complaint rate of 0% (I actually follow Perry Marshalls advice on emailing and segmenting my list, but I dont do this to comply with your Spam Rules, I do it to make more money) – I just feel that sometimes the email service providers push this information onto their clients to make their own jobs of ISP Whitelisting an 'Easier' task (which I know is difficult) – Also interesting to note, many of the big name internet marketers who use Infusion, dont use it for sending emails, as they are almost always breaking your 'Email Code of conduct'.

Previous post:

Next post: